Factor Performance and Factor Failure

Advisor Perspectives recently carried an article by Michael Nairne of Tacita Capital about factor investing. The article discussed a number of aspects of factor investing, including factor performance and periods of factor underperformance (factor failure). The remarkable thing about relative strength (termed momentum in his article) is the nice combination of strong performance and relatively short periods of underperformance that it affords the investor seeking alpha.

Mr. Nairne discusses a variety of factors that have been shown to generate excess returns over time. He includes a chart showing their performance versus the broad market.

Source: Advisor Perspectives/Tacita Capital (click on image to enlarge)

Yep, the one at the top is momentum.

All factors, even very successful ones, underperform from time to time. In fact, the author points out that these periods of underperformance might even contribute to their factor returns.

No one can guarantee that the return premia originating from these dimensions of the market will persist in the future. But, the enduring nature of the underlying causes – cognitive biases hardwired into the human psyche, the impact of social influences and incremental risk – suggests that higher expected returns should be available from these factor-based strategies.

There is another reason to believe that these strategies offer the prospect of future return premia for patient, long-term investors. These premia are very volatile and can disappear or go negative for many years. The chart on the following page highlights the percentage of 36-month rolling periods where the factor-based portfolios – high quality, momentum, small cap, small cap value and value – underperformed the broad market.

To many investors, three years of under-performance is almost an eternity. Yet, these factor portfolios underperformed the broad market anywhere from almost 15% to over 50% of the 36-month periods from 1982 to 2012. If one were to include the higher transaction costs of the factor-based portfolios due to their higher turnover, the incidence of underperformance would be more frequent. One of the reasons that these premia will likely persist is that many investors are simply not patient enough to stay invested to earn them.

The bold is mine, but I think Mr. Nairne has a good point. Many investors seem to believe in magic and want their portfolio to significantly outperform—all the time.

That’s just not going to happen with any factor. Not surprisingly, though, momentum has tended to have shorter stretches of underperformance than many other factors, a consideration that might have been partially responsible for its good performance over time. Mr. Nairne’s excellent graphic on periods of factor failure is reproduced below.

Source: Advisor Perspectives/Tacita Capital (click on image to enlarge)

Once again, whether you choose to try to harvest returns from relative strength or from one of the other factors, patience is an underrated component of actually receiving those returns. The market can be a discouraging place, but in order to reap good factor performance you have to stay with it during the inevitable periods of factor failure.

133 Responses to Factor Performance and Factor Failure

  1. […] You can’t mine return factors without some risk of underperformance. (Systematic Relative Strength) […]

  2. […] about optimal portfolio construction, this simple fact is often overlooked. Since momentum (relative strength) is generally one of the best-performing and most reliable return factors, that’s what we use to drive our global tactical allocation process. The idea is to own […]

  3. A terrific time Saturday night. We surprised my parents and they were thriled when they got there..Thank you! I used to be instructed by the photo booth person that photographs would be online. Where are they?

  4. Oh my goodness! an incredible article dude. Thanks Nonetheless I’m experiencing situation with ur rss . Don�t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anybody getting similar rss downside? Anybody who is aware of kindly respond. Thnkx

  5. I quite like reading through an article that will make men and women think. Also, thanks for allowing for me to comment!

  6. Wonderful article! We will be linking to this particularly great content on our site. Keep up the great writing.

  7. It certainly is practically not possible to come across well-advised americans on this issue, but you appear like you comprehend those things you’re preaching about! Bless You
    Kelly T. Hopp http://www.thewikipediaforum.com

  8. It’s practically unattainable to see well-qualified men and women on this subject, however, you appear like you comprehend the things you’re talking about! Cheers
    Norman A. Austin http://www.mjbt.info

  9. Jeff C. Dray says:

    It really is near extremely difficult to find well-educated individual on this issue, in addition you appear like you are familiar with which you’re writing on! Bless You
    Jeff C. Dray http://www.redstoneenergygroup.us

  10. It really is almost impossible to see well-educated men and women on this content, however , you seem like you be aware of the things that you’re preaching about! Many Thanks
    Helen L. Hale http://www.jocul.info

  11. It’s actually practically extremely difficult to encounter well-updated visitors on this content, then again you come across as like you fully understand those things you’re revealing! Regards

  12. It really is practically impossible to come across well-qualified visitors on this issue, however, you come across as like you be aware of what exactly you’re preaching about! Thanks A Lot

  13. Pardon me, does anyone know about that electrician in Tribeca by the name of New York Electrician, 94 Chambers St, New York, NY 10007 (646) 415-6723

  14. LOCKSMITH says:

    Yo, anyone ever hear about that electrical contractor on Chambers by the name of New York Electrician, 94 Chambers St, New York, NY 10007 (646) 415-6723

  15. facebook says:

    Newcomers to China may be faced with the question of “How can I open Facebook in China.
    You want to start inviting all your friends to join your group and interact with your group by sharing marketing tips that will help them to be success
    in marketing. If you are not keeping your page current and populated with new and interesting bits and pieces
    to read, you won.

  16. Heya, this is

    I like this website very much so much fantastic information.

  17. Not too mention

    I ought to appear into this and it would be a difficult job to go over this completely here.

  18. Accutane says:

    Outstanding post, I

    Some really interesting points you have written. Assisted me a lot, just what I was looking for : D.

  19. I am always searching online for articles that can help me. Thank you!

  20. web page says:

    Fantastic beat ! I would like to apprentice while you amend your site, how can i subscribe for a blog website? The account aided me a acceptable deal. I had been a little bit acquainted of this your broadcast offered bright clear idea

  21. Excellent post. I certainly appreciate this site.
    Stick with it!

    Visit my web page :: 5 vimax malaysia

  22. MicroSD64gb.net

    Factor Performance and Factor Failure • Systematic Relative Strength • Dorsey Wright Money Management Systematic Relative Strength

  23. I’ve been browsing on on the internet over three working hours nowadays, on the other hand in no way found virtually any attention-grabbing write-up such as the one you have. It is charming selling price enough to me. Personally, in the event many world-wide-web homeowners and people manufactured exceptional material as you performed, the online world will probably be much more very helpful than ever.

  24. 私は、アップ散策 欲望このためにサブスクライブするにはブログ 取得 最新更新は、したがって、ここで、私にできること、それは助けてください助けます。

  25. Greetings from Ohio! I’m bored to tears at work so I decided to browse your website on my iphone during lunch break. I enjoy the info you provide here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m surprised at how fast your blog loaded on my cell phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyways, awesome site!|

  26. Guides form the backbone of a river rafting company, and Grand Canyon Whitewater was pleased to warmlly welcome the guides of Diamond River Adventures too join the
    new outfit. ” Around 1900, he returned to Wisconsin and set up his own pattern-making shop. See more at: your holiday plans include a tropical destination, don’t forget to pack your UV Skinz.

  27. Although it appears a great deal of job and tine on how you can keep a weed
    eater, this moment saves you money that yyou may
    use in repairs if yoou neglect sustazining
    the weed eater.

  28. next page says:

    There’s no noise and diversion by waiter at standard times
    giving refreshments.

  29. Leonel says:

    I got this web page from my pal who told me about this web
    site and at the moment this time I am visiting this web
    page and reading very informative articles at this place.

  30. How toward grow concerning a personal loan

    Givve yourself harmon from thoughts. in case your ips under zero, a personal period regarding credit on your inventory will help.

    Qualifying as a loan may be very a lot dependent in your private
    credit. to larger including better loans, you’ll need to
    gobble venerable credit. there are a lot of totally different sources containing mortgages moreover sudden competitors is good for individuals.
    So, shindig your marching also progress to aintain your credit score rating high.

    Personal mortgage profile file inn / source tiill meeting Your particular
    financial savings particulars 1 whatsoever are youu seeking to dance?

    regenerate onn credit card demaand for payment compare original Personal loans Refinsideance An current mortgage 2 whatsoever are the mall print of
    your statement?stability so Refance $2,50zerounsettled tije period forty eight monthsAPR 21.99%month-to-month make up fordown $60zero three How a lot are you seeking to ?mortgage quantity four what is your credit score score?wonderful (seventy fivezero-eighty five0)laudable (700-749)truthful (sixty four0-6ninety nine)lacking (639 approximately less) revivify results Reset until nationwide Averages2 How a lot are you looking to borrow?mortgage quantity three what is your credit score? wonderful (seventy five0-85zero)worthy (7zero0-749)fair (64zero-6ninety nine)deprived (639 alternative less) revivify outcomes Reset upon national Averages 2 suchlike are the small print of your proposition?steadiness via Refinsideance $2,50zerounsettled term 48 monthsAPR 12.ninety nine%month-to-month rewarddown $67.zero6
    That method sudden loan doesn’t you to make use of an liability as collateral.
    fittingly,should you default next to a personal mortgage, sudden lender cannot automawtically annex a piece
    regarding your goods as fee as powerful loan. that is the primary purpose that private loams are tougher facing achieve.

    the lender does not lunch all resource to grab
    when you decide you can’t get going loan costs allmore.
    though striking lender can’t automatically confiscate
    your own ome or car, it will probably confiscate differet assortment actis.
    tbat consists off announcing late payments viasudden credit bureaaus , hiring a set agency, including submitting a
    proceedings towards you.

  31. homepage says:

    If eating 3 big meals make you more likely to stick to your weight loss diet, then eat 3.

  32. SOLD OUT says:

    送料無料 ドクターマーチン Dr.Martens 3ホール シューズ [ ブラック レッドストワート ] R15333615 ALSTUD ファブリック レディース [ 正規 あす楽 ]【P2】

  33. Monique functions within the methds as well as guidance of the clinic’s Facial
    Clinicians/ Cosmetic Nurses.

  34. You completed many good points there. I did particular searches on the issue and found many people can relate with along with your blog.
    Fantastic post!

  35. Anja says:

    According to the police affidavit, attorney Tallion Taylor
    knowingly had product that showed nude females believed by authorities to be under the age of 18.

  36. Florentina says:

    The COA (certificate of evaluation) and the lifetime of firms like
    Volume Sprays in the US is what finally I want to feel.

  37. That is probably due to the fact that the cd is produced by David Foster, and Bocelli
    is not singing the classics or trying major opera home functions, but songs made famous by motion pictures.

  38. Led Zeppelin is from a later wave of bands that did not have the
    very same cultural and social impact as the best
    bands of the 60s.

  39. bit.ly says:

    And he does not have the very same charm either.

  40. Queen has to be 1 #. Just beatles, led are bearable.
    Queen is most innovative band of perpetuity including bohemian rhapsody, the great king ratwe will rock you,
    we are the champs, the millionair’s waltz, phony. they are actually
    ingenious. Ahead of their time.

  41. bit.ly says:

    Located at the mouth of the Charles River as it enters Massachusetts Bay, Boston played a key role in the advanced war and as a significant seaport and trade center in the early
    years of America’s history.

  42. bit.ly says:

    Here is a selection of tunes included on the program and similar
    choices in the timeless rock category.

  43. All excellent tunes. All great albums. 1968-1980
    but still the very best and constantly be the very best.

  44. The Lion King has been performed on stage over
    5300 times according to Wikipedia New york city is now the
    home location of the Broadway Musical.

  45. With record breaking ticket office numbers and an outstanding array of film and music awards, it’s fairly simple to see that The Lion King was an instantaneous Walt Disney
    success and classic.

  46. In 1942 four witnesses saw the ship get in Table
    Bay and in 1959 the Magelhaen nearly collided with the phantom ship.

  47. Sadly, the band transmogrified after the death of guitarist/musicologist Brian Jones in July 1969.

  48. Many Americans understand exactly what opera is however can’t appear making much sense of it.
    The recontextualized” or crossover” sounds learnt through Evancho, nevertheless, do understand the classical style of singing, splendidly so.

    Her singing releases listeners from mystification with operatic noise.

  49. shal.asia says:

    If the movie moves you emotionally, maybe the phase play will too,
    but I don’t find that the tale analyzes its psychological core more successfully on phase.

  50. In every way the kid has actually left him.

  51. The Tudors was fantastic and I am now delighting in seeing Natalie Dormer (Queen Ann) play Margaery Tyrell in Game of Thrones.

  52. The band has actually produced numerous hit albums over the years, particularly classics such as The Dark Side
    of the Moon and The Wall.

  53. Didn’t think I would ever see that motion picture again considering that it frightened me half
    to death as a kid, but needed to see him with him in it, and it had not been so scary this time.

  54. Lion King says:

    The Lion King, Jr. is a vibrant ensemble program with cast members CONTINUOUSLY moving in and
    out of numbers.

  55. Another plays John as the offender, insisting that the band remains together
    to enable the big songlists of initial McCartney
    songs to be tape-recorded, consequently providing his long
    time pal the credit he was worthy of.

  56. The phase version of Disney’s Lion King commemorates its five thousandth efficiencies in London’s West End.

  57. Attempt a search and see for yourself, it’s not tough to discover
    a pre 1966 photo of young Paul with an expression that completely translates with the Paul McCartney
    we can all easily relate to the guy we know today.

  58. They attempt to replicate the Rock N Roll and Pop culture that was so present in the past, however cannot do so due
    to the fact that it’s become from time.

  59. I bet that many individuals were suprised or were just merely in awe of David Cook’s efficiency, singing Music of
    the Night from The Phantom of the Opera.

  60. Didn’t think I would ever enjoy that motion picture once more since it scared me half
    to death as a kid, but needed to see him with him
    in it, and it had not been so frightening this time.

  61. lunspace.com says:

    Perhaps the cd’s biggest hit was Interstellar Overdrive,” a distinctly psychedelic title and tune, throughout an extremely trippy time, if you remember. In 1965, lead guitarist Syd Barrett, struggling with mental problems, was replaced by his good friend David Gilmour.

  62. Some accounts vary about whether it was the 9th November or the
    11th September, so lets simply state late in 1966.

  63. With the passage of time and the big publicity machine that sent out
    the Beatle’s faces out on everything from mugs
    to posters, it’s possible that our memories have replaced the baby dealt with Paul with the ‘brand-new’ Paul and
    now can not tell them apart.

  64. Deep Purple is at the very same level that Led Zeppelin (as some other
    bands are).

  65. In its 18th year, The Lion King continues to be among the most popular phase musicals on the planet.

  66. His height and stature modifications. Early on he’s small and small.
    There are even a few photos that come around 1966 at the end of
    the US trip where he looks brief and dumpy. Certainly not taller than John by any huge degree.

  67. That way I picked up Carlos Clarens’ Scary Films (pub 1968) and
    both the Alan Frank motion picture treasury editions included in your post for a few cents each.

  68. That’s when I stumbled onto a story I ‘d heard many times prior
    to and, if its real, it’s the greatest deception of modern-day times.

  69. He played the villain in Mission Impossible II with Tom Cruise and he missed out on playing the role of Hugh Jackman in the movie wolverine as
    the filming of the motion picture objective was delayed for
    2 months.

  70. Ashli says:

    Finding the correct spot to your tent, gathering firewood and making dinner are all
    a lot more durable after darkness settles in. That is significantly important in case you are not used to doing things in the dark.
    Avoid this hazard fully, by discovering satisfactory shelter long before the
    solar goes down.

  71. Vaughn says:

    Hi there everyone, it’s my first visit at this site, and piece of writing is in fact fruitful in favor of me, keep up posting these types of content.

  72. I ‘d heard that you simply needed to order lion king tickets a year in advance of time, and I only have three months left in the city.

  73. They sourced two clear photos and set to work with the
    best forensic strategies, anticipating to put an end to the rumour at last.

    Their findings only added fuel to the fire and led to, according to their work, a high probability that Paul McCartney pre 1966 and post
    1966 are two various people.

  74. Bono, the lead singer of the group, continues to
    be a social activist on the world scene, going
    to difficulty areas with the consistency of a United Nations ambassador.

  75. Not only did they change the face of music and songwriting, but also in fashion, and culture.

  76. It’s really just one bothersome fanatic with numerous useranames.

  77. Lion King says:

    The Lion King musical functions stars in animal outfits as well as giant, hollow puppets.

  78. The Beatles, living and dead, never seemed to resolve the Hoax in any interviews.

  79. Free Report; Why Hire a Paint Contractor, How to Hire a Paint Contractor, Question for Paint Contractor.

  80. Sophie says:

    This item: MAGS: The People Part of Prepping: How to Plan, Build, and Organize a Mutual Assistance
    Group in a Survival Situation.

  81. In 1942 4 witnesses saw the ship go into Table Bay and in 1959
    the Magelhaen almost hit the phantom ship.

  82. Led Zeppelin is from a later wave of bands that did not have the
    very same cultural and social effect as the best
    bands of the 60s.

  83. See and try a search on your own, it’s not difficult to find a pre 1966 photo of
    young Paul with an expression that perfectly equates with the
    Paul McCartney we can all quickly identify with the guy we
    know today.

  84. Remembering it was the sixties and nearly everything the Beatles touched has actually been re-released sometimes given that.
    If the switch took place, then management within the releasing business,
    first EMI and then Apple, to some degree, have to have understood
    the fact and therefore, doctoring and flooding the market with pictures of a younger Paul to match the older isn’t difficult.
    Implausible, maybe, however possible.

  85. Chester says:

    Also, try making fire when you are not in a survival situation so you know you can do it if the need arises.

  86. Not only did they change the face of music and songwriting, however likewise in fashion, and culture.

  87. The Lion King is created for the masses, just like summer season smash hits in the film world.

  88. The animated movie, The Lion King, is Disney’s 32nd function in Walt Disneys Animated
    Classic series.

  89. After Film Magic (the hardback edition is imagined), behind-the-scenes
    posts in Cinefantastique publication fortunately became more technically interested in visual and makeup results (prior to Fangoria and Cinefex took over in 1979).

  90. Absolutely nothing will ever be as impactful, influential and revolutionary as The Beatles and The Rolling Stones when it pertains
    to Rock bands.

  91. Lion King says:

    Obviously, the costumes for the primary lions had actually been fascinating, alternating in between having highlighting the lion masks and the human face.

  92. The stage production of the Lion King includes the same legendary story as the animated film,
    including the same classic tunes, such as Can You Feel The Love Tonight
    and Hakuna Matata.

  93. The facial hair all of a sudden showed up after 1966.

  94. Physician Who- This character initially came
    onto our screens in 1963 and has since had numerous incarnations and costume
    modifications.

  95. A number of possibilities are that 1966-68 would make Paul
    24 to 26 years and that’s a time in an average aging pattern where a person does change quite a lot.

  96. Bev says:

    Many people like to camp to get away from the stress of their everyday lives.

  97. You’ll also have fewer lyrics to worry about memorizing, which suggests you’ll
    feel more unwinded.

  98. When Ms. Evancho does sing opera arias, she does not
    sing them operatically-nor does she plan to, nor do her listeners desire her to.
    I enjoy Domingo’s Nessun Dorma more than Pavarotti’s Nessun Dorma, which I find pretty however insubstantial -and I enjoy Ms.
    Evancho’s Nessun Dorma which, in her capable hands, becomes such a
    various performance that I do not even find
    them competing with each other.

  99. And he all of a sudden seems to be totally ignorant about
    his place as a celeb and his relationship with the media
    and the repercussions of anything he says.

  100. I ‘d never really provided it anymore thought beyond that.

  101. If there was a switch, then the most extraordinary
    part of the whole thing is the male who took Paul James McCartney’s location has turned out
    to be an amazing singer/songwriter and artist.

  102. All in the exact same band.

  103. The enhanced requirement for expert translation services has actually occurred as a result of the development in world
    trade considering that the very early 1970s.

  104. Get expert advertising and marketing ideas straight to your
    inbox, and become a better marketer.

  105. Brandie says:

    I have done a podcast in the past about prepping terms and acaronyms but it;s been a long
    time so I decided to do an updated version.

  106. Rochell says:

    Innovative Ideas For Feature Walls By: GoodContent - Tired of a boring backyard?

  107. Leonel says:

    Russia is not only stepping up its military presence in Ukraine,
    the superpower just conducted naval exercises with its nuclear submarines under the North Pole If
    not prepping for World War 3 , which is what many fear, what could possibly be the point?

  108. Louis says:

    It is extremely important to use a soft cloth in order
    to prevent scratching the surface.

  109. Charlotte says:

    (for a high quality paint job don’t skimp on products, it’s not worth it) Put about 4 wet coats of
    primer on the car and let it cure for a day or two
    preferably in the sun.

  110. Nigel says:

    Pick up all your mess, and pick up a few pieces of other litters that is not yours.

  111. Dale says:

    To keep away from blistered and chapped feet in your camping trip, convey
    a bar of soap alongside!

  112. An outstanding share! I have just forwarded this onto a co-worker who was conducting a little research on this.
    And he actually ordered me breakfast due to the fact that I found it for him…

    lol. So allow me to reword this…. Thank YOU for
    the meal!! But yeah, thanx for spending time to discuss this
    matter here on your internet site.

  113. Usually I don’t learn article on blogs, but I wwould like to say that this
    write-up very forced mee too check out and do it! Your writing style has been surprised me.
    Thanks, very nice article.

  114. Service providers gain clients by giving them attractive saving schemes,
    inexpensive and under-budget deals or a handful of beneficial in addition to ineffective giveaways then they start cheating and also
    letting clients bang their heads on wall surfaces as they familiarize that exactly what an actual thing, they have actually obtained, is only
    their dollars have been burglarized for couple of bad services.

  115. Candra says:

    Greetings from California! I’m bored to death at work so I ddecided to check out your website on my iphone during lunch break.
    I enjoy the info you present here and can’t wawit to take a look when I get home.

    I’m amazed at how fast your blog loaded onn my cell phone ..
    I’m not even usig WIFI, juszt 3G .. Anyways, wonderful site!

  116. www.kamot.si says:

    And the longer the paint stays on the metal components, the extra protected they’re
    going to be.

  117. Avis says:

    Fixing, replacing and protecting the paint on kitchen cupboard shelves
    is a prolonged however ultimately rewarding course of.

  118. Seth says:

    Ask a park ranger or a tour information to let you know about all the
    places to take a look at while you are camping. It is a good idea
    in order that you realize you are getting probably the most
    out of your camping experience, you do not want
    to take a camping journey and miss out on a fun expertise.

  119. Then let them gather all of the food of those
    good years which might be coming, and store up the
    grain for meals in the cities below Pharaoh’s authority, and allow them to guard
    it. Let the meals develop into as a reserve for the land
    for the seven years of famine which is able to happen in the land of Egypt, so that the land will not perish in the course of the famine.” Genesis forty one:
    34-36.

  120. you’re actually a just right webmaster. The website loading pace
    is incredible. It kind of feels that you’re doing any distinctive trick.
    Furthermore, The contents are masterwork. you have done a magnificent job in this subject!

  121. To hack gems in Clash of Clans with no acquiring them, will demand you to
    manipulate the calculations in the recreation.

  122. hylunia skin care amazon

  123. garcinia cambogia benefits diabetes gnc thermo cla customer reviews arabica green coffee beans international buyers free informations acai pregnancy safe mangosteen juice concentrate p57 hoodia gordonii china southern baggage red yeast rice contraindications chitosan heparin induced guar gum health concerns muscletech hydroxycut gnc mega resveratrol resveratrol health benefits

  124. famous hawk says:

    It will ask you if you want to “Show this Recommendation on my profile” or “Hide
    this Recommendation on my profile. This should all be paid for by the commission you’re receiving.
    The only thing that stays the same is his bubbly energetic personality and the big black frame glasses.

  125. If some one wishes to be updated with most up-to-date technologies
    then he must be pay a visit this web page and be up to
    date everyday.

  126. My partner and I stumbled over here different web address and thought I might check things out.
    I like what I see so i am just following you. Look forward
    to looking into your web page again.

  127. kamas maroc says:

    Great blog here! Additionally your web site a lot up
    very fast! What web host are you the usage of? Can I am
    getting your affiliate hyperlink in your host? I want my site loaded up as quickly as yours lol

  128. Ihr Blick und Ihre Hände strichen über die tollen Latexsachen im Schrank bilder blowjob.

  129. Sceleb.com says:

    This is my first time pay a visit at here and i am genuinely pleassant
    to read everthing at one place.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *