If You’re Going to Be Active, Be Systematic

Michael Batnick of The Irrelevant Investor cites statistics from SPIVA showing that 79.59% of large-cap managers have failed to beat their benchmark over the last 10 years then makes these astute observations:

I believe the days of superstar stock pickers is a thing of the past. For many of these professionals, career risk is too large a hurdle to overcome. Straying too far from the index keeps their returns looking a lot like it and fees generally eat up any alpha they might earn. Aside from career risk, here are a few other risk factors to consider that can negatively affect a portfolio manager.

  1. Maybe they get divorced
  2. Maybe they lose a key analyst
  3. Maybe they go through a bad stretch and start second guessing themselves
  4. Maybe they leave for another company.
  5. Maybe they want to spend more time with their kids.

This is just too many maybes and why I believe that if you’re going to deviate from the index, it’s important to do so in a systematic way. With quantitative strategies, you understand there will be times when it falls out of favor, in fact you sign up for that ahead of time. However, if a stock picker hits a rough patch, you don’t know they will ever regain the ability it appeared they once had. Furthermore, it can be difficult to ascertain what caused them to outperform in the first place; that whole thing about distinguishing luck from skill.

When considering active strategies, it’s important for us that we’re not relying on anyone’s intuition, expertise, or mental or emotional well being. We don’t want our PMs speaking with management, doing channel checks or backing out the cash. We want them to follow their models with as little interference as humanly possible.

A focus on process over short-term results is a hallmark of DWA. We long ago recognized the need to systematize strategy decision rules in order to minimize the negative effect of human emotion on investment results. Part of the reason that we were comfortable with this is because of the mountain of research on momentum which suggests that momentum is a premier investment factor. With something that effective over time, why mess with it? Honing our craft is an ongoing process, but we take great pride in the level of consistency of our investment process over time.

Too often, our industry notes the percentage of active managers that fail to beat an index and comes to the wrong conclusion—essentially throwing the baby out with the bathwater. A much more telling statistic would be the percentage of systematic vs. non-systematic investment managers that beat an index over time. I suspect that the former number would be much higher than the latter.

The relative strength strategy is NOT a guarantee. There may be times where all investments and strategies are unfavorable and depreciate in value.

HT: Jim O’Shaughnessey

12 Responses to If You’re Going to Be Active, Be Systematic

  1. Jeremy says:

    Thanks for putting me on to that post - I think this part really sums it up:

    “When considering active strategies, it’s important for us that we’re not relying on anyone’s intuition, expertise, or mental or emotional well being.”

    As always is the case with trading, it comes down to human intervention and emotions that messes things up. That is why I am convinced that having a few systematic systems ready and able is going to be key going forward.

  2. seo dc says:

    Many small companies prefer to hire SEO specialists as consultants rather than full time employees, unless they have a certain amount of
    websites that need to be continuously maintained
    and optimized. Improving Site Structure - This
    second part tells you how to properly structure URLs. But in general here are the services that an online business
    owner should expect from SEO experts and other agencies and
    consultants:. Tests with a model like Page - Rank have shown that the system is not infallible.

  3. dc seo says:

    If your site is relatively sound, the most important results for
    you to consider are the keyword hits. So what are you going to put in their search box is “website optimization tips”.

    While effective SEO needn’t be difficult, it does
    take work. In this way, it is informed about the kind of information that a surfer
    is looking for.

  4. When some oone searches forr his vital thing, therefore
    he/she wants to be available that iin detail, thus that thing is maintainedd over here.

  5. Elias says:

    Woodworking is a superb pastime to take up. Woodworking expertise mean you can make furnishings
    or out of doors decor to spruce up your private home.

  6. Jerold says:

    En tiempos de desarrollo, el costo pasa a ser un tema secundario, por el hecho de que como la compañía gana dinero no le importa obsequiar un poco.

  7. I take pleasure in, lead to I found just what I was taking a look for.

    You have ended my four day long hunt! God Bless you man. Have a nice
    day. Bye

  8. Arthur says:

    Pretty! This has been an extremely wonderful post.
    Thank you for supplying these details.

  9. Hi, i think that i noticed you visited my site thus i came to go back the want?.I am attempting to in finding issues to enhance my site!I guess its good
    enough to make use of some of your concepts!!

  10. Suisse says:

    I really like reading an article that can make people think.
    Also, many thanks for allowing for me to comment!

  11. Bryce Berny says:

    A system is more than just a process. It is a sustained, multi-contextual and dynamic entity created by concrete and intangible constituents. As http://systematic.systems points out, a wheel without a road is nothing more than a circle.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *