Cage Match: Pension vs. 401k

Chuck Jaffe recently had a good retirement article on Marketwatch.  He covered a number of topics, especially longevity estimates, but he also had the most succinct explanation of the difference between how a pension and a 401k plan works.  Here it is:

In the days when corporate pensions were the primary supplement to Social Security, Americans were able to generate a lifetime income, effectively, by putting everyone’s lifetime in a pool, then saving and managing the pooled assets to meet the target.

The individuals in a pension plan would live out their lives, but the actuaries and money managers would adjust the pool based on the life experience of the group. Thus, if the group had a life expectancy of living to age 75 – which statistically would mean that half of the pensioners would die before that age, and half would die afterwards – longevity risk was balanced out by the group experience.

Now that we have shifted to making individuals responsible for generating their lifetime income stream, there is no pool that shares the risk of outliving assets.

The bold is mine, but the distinction should be pretty clear.  With a pension plan, you’re covered if you live a long time—because your extra payouts are covered by the early mortality of some of the other participants.  It’s a shared-risk pool.

In a 401k, there’s only one participant.  You.  In other words, you’re on your own.

With a 401k, the only way to cover yourself adequately is to assume you are going to live a long time and save a lot to reserve for it.  If you’ve got enough assets to cover yourself to age 100, the most negative outcome is that your heirs will think very fondly of you.  If you are covered for only a few years of retirement, you’ll need to either keep working, eat Alpo, move in with your kids, or possibly take up motorcycle racing and sky-diving.  None of those sound like great options to me.

117 Responses to Cage Match: Pension vs. 401k

  1. Asking questions are really nice thing if you are not understanding anything
    totally, however this piece of writing gives fastidious understanding even.

  2. It looks like pleasant publish, on the other hand it just 1 side with the medal. Awesome reading anyway, I usually appreciated superior brain teaser and solid amount of pleasant information.

  3. Good day! I simply wish to give an enormous thumbs up for the nice data you will have right here on this post. I will likely be coming again to your weblog for extra soon.

  4. After examine a number of of the blog posts on your website now, and I really like your approach of blogging. I bookmarked it to my bookmark website record and might be checking back soon. Pls try my site as nicely and let me know what you think.

  5. If you’ve got done proper analysis, you don’t need to fear with this loan.
    The auto industry has suffered the most in the existing economic
    crisis. An individual doesn’t always take personal for many express purposes prefer to
    purchase a motor vehicle or bike or for property.

  6. You should also try and clean break dust off at regular intervals as if you leave it
    too long the dust will be baked into your wheels.
    Having a home elevator is very convenient and helpful for someone who lives with a disabled or elderly person.
    residents trust usually include in their bid the removal of your old roof.

  7. Assets – While your assets will not play a significant role in how much
    money you can borrow, they will be required to
    determine your overall financial fitness. Electronic certificates can be saved to your computer and printed out for your records.

    On the other hand, to the prospective buyer, it is an indicator that you have not maintained the property.

  8. If the region you are living in is warmer and hot then equal amount of water is required to be
    mixed with glycol based antifreeze. Electronic certificates
    can be saved to your computer and printed out for your records.
    There are also things that home inspectors can’t see like the wiring, plumbing and
    insulation inside the walls.

  9. ambien says:

    very good put

    Thanks, are you

  10. Hey there, You have done an excellent job. I will certainly digg it and personally suggest to my friends. I’m confident they will be benefited from this site.|

  11. This is very attention-grabbing, You are a very professional blogger. I’ve joined your feed and sit up for looking for extra of your wonderful post. Additionally, I’ve shared your web site in my social networks|

  12. mortgage says:

    In case of an annuity payment system, the regular settlement remains the very same quantity throughout the

  13. Lara says:

    wonderful post, very informative. I ponder why the opposite experts of this sector do
    not notice this. You should continue your writing. I am sure,
    you’ve a great readers’ base already!

  14. Excellent goods from you, man. I have understand your stuff previous to
    and you’re just too fantastic. I actually like what you have
    acquired here, certainly like what you’re saying and the way in which you say it.
    You make it entertaining and you still care for
    to keep it smart. I cant wait to read far more from you. This is really a great website.

  15. I used to be recommended this website through my cousin. I’m
    not sure whether or not this publish is written by way of
    him as no one else know such special approximately my difficulty.
    You are wonderful! Thanks!

  16. Sonja says:

    If you wish for to get a good deal from this article then you have
    to apply these methods to your won website.

  17. Heather says:

    Those that rely on whitehat link structure methods invest a bunch
    of time communicating to other blog writers, however
    the most effective Search Engine Optimization consultants receive
    a ton of guest blog post demands week after week.

  18. The impact on your content advertising: See to it that
    your teams are meeting at least regular monthly to go over trends that they’re seeing as well as how those trends can be used to impact the advertising and marketing techniques.

  19. Lynne says:

    Visitor writing a blog made use of to be preferred a couple
    of years earlier, yet Google has actually secured down on it recently considering that
    individuals were abusing it, as well as just guest blogging to obtain links
    for Search Engine Optimization (often called backlinks).

  20. Berniece says:

    Concentrate on quality web link building methods and also methods to avoid future abnormal links notifications in Google
    Webmaster Devices which will be complied with by fines that could last – well – permanently –
    relying on exactly what you have depended on.

  21. Zak says:

    Write for your readers, as well as the SEO will look after itself via social networks as well as all-natural back
    links from individuals who like as well as want to cite your works.

  22. Henry says:

    He also prefers to create various blogs regarding Search Engine Optimization and in the above article, he
    is sharing the upcoming fads in SEO this year.

  23. Stefan says:

    With inputs from sector specialists as well as examining the common fad, we bring you the
    upcoming SEO fads in 2015.

  24. Adolfo says:

    Our managed Search Engine Optimization and social projects as well as
    high domain name authority web link structure will certainly raise your visibility as well
    as organic internet search engine website traffic.

  25. Don says:

    The majority of the time as well as for most of business one of the most difficult component of Search Engine Optimization is that thinking of appealing, useful as well as helpful components on their specific niches consistently for their possible customers.

  26. Celsa says:

    > Consistently one thing we should bear in mind in SEO that is if we compose Excellent and also special
    Articles that is interest to check out for a user not for search engines
    this is the one policy always survives you in SERP.

  27. It’s reveals the users how to be competitive on the natural position as well as provides valuable ideas in varioius critical
    stages in a SEO campaign, such as keyword study,
    on-page Search Engine Optimization as well as web link structure.

  28. The body’s recuperation from these workout sessions,
    and any added muscle, make your physical body’s basal metabolic rate rise somewhat.

  29. Caren says:

    This basic conflict of passion has actually highlighted a struggle for power that is greatly responsible
    for the SEO sector’s continuous state of flux as well as its interminable however
    slow-moving move back to its natural origins.

  30. Jamal says:

    For my own company, Search Engine Optimization has actually played a remarkable function, and also I would
    certainly not be right here without it. In this the program you
    will discover the wise Search Engine Optimization strategies
    I utilize to draw countless individuals every day from everywhere on the internet.

  31. Bryan says:

    Article submission (for internet search engine optimization functions) is a large no-no for me in 2015.

  32. Joann says:

    In this component of our Search Engine Optimization advertising training
    course I speak about writing a blog as well as guest blog writing for SEO.

  33. Larry says:

    Pretty PDF keyword ranking records don’t discuss whether or
    not Search Engine Optimization is working – your
    conversions, income and ROI do.

  34. Ute says:

    . Are your SEO employee and/or specialists making recommendations
    to improve the customer experience?

  35. Marcelo says:

    Right here are a few of the greatest, crucial modifications
    that your Search Engine Optimization initiatives are visiting have to adapt to for
    finest results as you continue via 2015.

  36. Sadie says:

    No matter the size of a company, from small company to organization, it is a vital
    element in today’s successful B2B SEO variety of consumers
    executing searches for neighborhood remedies and also solutions
    on cell phones is escalating.

  37. Latoya says:

    2014 teemed with giant updates to regional search results page,
    and it is unidentified what sort of modifications 2015 will certainly bring.

  38. Gudrun says:

    Skyscraper as well as other white-hat, material driven Search Engine Optimization techniques might work wonderful in a sector where there are countless marketing professionals and blog writers who
    on a regular basis produce content, have active Twitter
    followings, and will happily link to various other excellent content.

  39. imessage for windows

    Cage Match: Pension vs. 401k • Systematic Relative Strength • Dorsey Wright Money Management Systematic Relative Strength

  40. It’s actually very complicated in this active life to listen news on Television, so I
    just use world wide web for that reason, and get the
    most up-to-date news.

  41. I bet you’re thinking that you’ve tried every trick in the world to try to lose your stubborn belly fat,
    just with no results. I do about fifteen minutes of these a day and on exercise I do, is to simply get a small stool about nine inches to a foot high and then do step ups using
    that. And that my friend is when the quick fat loss

  42. Tamara says:

    For newest information you have to pay a visit web and on web I found this website as a best web site for hottest updates.

  43. modern Style says:

    you are in point of fact a good webmaster. The web site loading velocity is
    amazing. It sort of feels that you are doing any distinctive trick.
    Also, The contents are masterpiece. you’ve done a great task in this topic!

  44. New analysis has found that 70 per cent of consumers will not
    purchase anything on Black Friray and Cyber Monday, discouraging small business homeowners from investing too
    much of their money and time on oone of tthe busiest procuring events of tthe 12 months.

  45. Frieda says:

    The aroma of hookah is also more pleasant compared to cigarette
    smoking, because the tobacco tends to be mixed with fruit or floral tastes.

  46. Webseite says:

    Ich mache auch gerne Haus – oder Hotelbesuche, Du hast die Wahl.

  47. says:

    This is important for the stove’s efficiency, since some pellet
    fuels have high ash contents, which makes it necessary for the
    user to use only the type of pellets recommended by the manufacturer.
    Sometimes you even have the option to purchase these additions separately.
    What’s left of the food is not digestible and is met
    with water.

  48. Lily says:

    You are meant to put the box in your oven on top of the grate where your coal fire will certainly be.
    Stack some coal in addition to this little box and afterwards light fuse with a lengthy candle or
    BARBEQUE grill lighter.

  49. Jude says:

    Mother and father may have invaded My Area and also Facebook, yet they are not likely
    to appear at the hookah lounge.

  50. site says:

    The bags are made from different materials that range from
    leather to suede. This contrast produces a strong visual effect, very suitable
    for girls and young women, giving a chic and dynamic appearance.

    Heel Pain A Huge Degenerative Processes (Fasciosis) Without The
    Need For Inflammed Joints.

  51. Sehr guter Post! Ich schaue mir sehr gerne Serien im Internet an. Vorallem liebe ich Amazon Prime

  52. says:

    I took haof within the challenge as a lead of QA workforce and also carried out testingg of softwarfe program application and its interplay with hardware merchandise.

  53. Sehr schöner Beitrag! Ich gucke mir sehr gerne Serien im Web an. Vorallem mag ich Netflix.

  54. It’s likely to evaluate this blog in various approaches. Your unique
    perspective shall be based on your take on things and your individual situations.
    There are quite a few basic concepts on this
    planet that happen to be time-tested and found that they are true.
    One of these is that it’s better to apply a single new notion separately,
    and learn the idea effectively, before you decide to
    move ahead to a thriving principle. This is incredibly important
    when you are able to clearly view just what are going to be valuable
    and worth keeping and what won’t. While you’re much more familiar with this, it is possible
    to begin to incorporate some procedures and exclude others.

    For more facts along with viewpoints, please make
    an effort to go to us, an important site.

  55. I am truly thankful to the owner of this website who has shared this wonderful piece of writing at here.

  56. Ihave submitted my pf type on 2 feb 2011,however pf division has taken my
    form on twenty sixth april 2011,from then my pf iis pending.

  57. Willie says:

    “Content that links back to your site does not have to be in your confront with precise or partial match, and even top quality keyword phrases as your support content,” claims Vaibhav Kakkar, co-founder of RankWatch,
    which supplies back links and on-site SEO analysis in addition to keeping track of

  58. Don says:

    It can also increase search quantity for your web
    site and also hence it is going to be prominent in 2015.

  59. Leandro says:

    So, you must aim to focus increasingly more
    on social networks strategy in 2015 to ensure that you could create
    appropriate as well as targeted web traffic to your website.

  60. Dominic says:

    Search Engine Optimization might transform as well as advance
    however it will certainly still be just one of the most effective online marketing methods that
    businesses can apply to achieve their objectives
    such as producing much more appropriate website visitor, drawing in prospective customers,
    increasing sales, as well as preserving client loyalty.

  61. Felix says:

    Question-Answer Sites are likewise one of the most
    effective choices of Off-Page Search Engine Optimization Techniques.

  62. Lara says:

    As opposed to SEO being of its very own unique discipline, it will certainly be
    more often used as a fundamental component that is influenced by (and influences) the other aspects
    of marketing (social networks as well as material).

  63. Alina says:

    Search Engine Optimization will certainly not be a separated division, yet come
    to be completely integrated with other elements of advertising.

  64. Gerald says:

    I was using wood coals and also i enjoyed the temperature drop as i
    made use of the hookah.

  65. Just like anything connected with this blog, or something similar, to realize your objectives, having a fundamental understanding of this will certainly help.
    While you certainly will find success at some point, it is going
    to be hard. You’re going to have problems, even if these principles are quite
    sound. Should you attempt to make things work, hastening the process is not going
    to help you in any way shape or form. You definitely cannot put things off since this
    will make things worse as well. You won’t be frustrated
    if you merely take things one step at a time.
    us is an outstanding source of information that is recommended
    if you want to clarify things even more.

  66. Carley says:

    When other center upkeep for food store firms cannot satisfy your requirements, get in touch with
    Advanced Service Solutions.

  67. Etta says:

    For many years, our Search Engine Optimization experts have actually made use of task management systems, SmartSheets, Excel
    workbooks and various other software program to assist us in producing SEO

  68. Barrett says:

    I clarified that I’m focussed on building a personal
    brand as well as it’s trivial for me to place for SEO.”.

  69. Rex says:

    So, These Off Web page Search Engine Optimization Strategies are
    efficient as well as still powerful at one condition, Do not Spam Over There.

  70. Fran says:

    This seo community has a history (some of which is taken a look at in the above quote) of making, at
    least, questionable studies.

  71. Sehr guter Artikel! Ich gucke mir sehr gerne Videos im Internet an. Vorallem liebe ich Amazon Prime Video.

  72. I was suggested this blog by means of my cousin. I’m not certain whether or not this put up is written by means of him as no one else realize such specified about my difficulty.
    You’re amazing! Thank you!

  73. Felisha says:

    Property Handling, on Stand M942 at Facilities Program, assists organisations to manage their resources as
    well as enhance services performance, providing 4 products –
    Asset Insight Supervisor, Program Idea Supervisor, Integrated Danger Manager as well
    as Resource Manager – together with consultancy, systems application and also training.

  74. Nicki says:

    It’s impossible to talk about the idea of SEO post without bringing Google’s
    quality standards.

  75. Shawnee says:

    You need to have a content-based Search Engine Optimization method in 2015, without a simply content-based approach, It will be
    harder to attract attention from the group.

  76. After over a decade of learning what jobs, we came up with the Search Engine Optimization Roadmap,
    ” a tracker arranged by discipline for easy delegation and also conference agenda conversations.

  77. You must deal with these problems as quickly as you can, but this could just be achieved if
    you check your Search Engine Optimization tasks regularly.

  78. Kendall says:

    Prior to we get into the 5 on-page SEO approaches you could use to provide
    your website that rank boost, initially make sure you have these essentials carried
    out on your website currently:.

  79. Kasey says:

    Several so called SEO professionals” today will certainly tell you that users will not check out everything and will avert if the content is too long, yet results do not lie.

  80. Jefferson says:

    In order to win the Search Engine Optimization battle against your rivals, you must
    do something that puts you in advance of everyone else.

  81. Edwina says:

    It can also increase search volume for your site and thus it is going to be popular in 2015.

  82. JustLanded is a responsive touchdown page theme that’s loaded with choices andd tools.

  83. For honeymoons in Belize or romantic getaways in Belize’s jungles, pertained to the
    primary deluxe hotel and also experience real experience among Maya Ruins
    and spotless rain forest.

  84. Johnson says:

    Okay, so the basic foundational strategy for this six pack abs how to is set pretty well.
    What you need to learn about this program is
    that it can help you get the six flat abs that you desire by telling you the truth.
    Keep reading and we’ll share with you the best exercises you can do to get rock hard abs that look as
    if they were made from stone.

  85. Combine this seach with Zapier automation that saves Twitter search engine
    results to a Bing Docs spreadsheet and you will rapidly begin building a list of people
    to contact on Twitter whenever you launch your software.

  86. Cory says:

    Nice replies in return of this query with real arguments and describing everything regarding that.

  87. Jennie says:

    No chance could I pay for all the ones I would like to head to, but keeping active in the conversation around it on Twitter helps to keep
    me current by what’s happening. There’s no excuse becoming totally
    out from the cycle.

  88. Edgar says:

    Carry small cereal containers, juice drinks and fruit, and preserve
    them tied up high in the bushes. Your kids can then hunt these foods
    when they get up. It is a wonderful means
    to spice up the whole camping trip.

  89. This page truly has all the information and facts I needed about this subject and didn’t know who to ask.

  90. Christin says:

    One of the more frequent systems utilizes varying voltages
    on this wire to communicate with the computer systems inside of the car.

  91. Most boards will let you may have your affiliate link seem in your signature section.

  92. It’s an awesome paragraph designed for all the internet users; they will get advantage from it I am sure.

  93. Elena says:

    All such services as well as facilities that are offered to the
    customers are the main stage however the 2nd stage
    is the major passion that set the foundation of the company IT solutions.

  94. river says:

    visine drops on acne

  95. Tiffany says:

    However, no matter the name you offer, you need to give a working telephone number– this will allow
    social services to call you once again if they need
    any type of additional information to help them explore your credit record.

  96. Joanna says:

    Nonetheless, it’s depressing to see your personal sector in the headlines struck for suspicious payment practices.

  97. Leslee says:

    However, in Pirate Kings, so far I have never found any common utilization of advertisements or pop ups.

  98. If you want to get much from this paragraph then you have
    to apply these strategies to your won weblog.

  99. Coy says:

    Internet Marketing is certainly not a trend; it is the strategy to simply take for your needs
    in a world which progressively counting on online to locate products and services along with make
    acquisition decisions.

  100. Ouida says:

    Well, yes and no. You can use applications like MeetEdgar to bunch social
    media updates and routine when you want all of them to create.

  101. Jackson says:

    With all the various social media marketing as well as other platforms available, but effective advertising and
    marketing is much more complex than in the past.

  102. Lo mio fue una reforma integral en la capital española bastante grande y el plazo de entrega fue
    de cinco meses, tardarón cinco meses y nueve días
    algo más de lo que correspondía en el contrato pero
    fue algo justificado. Doy mi opinion para asistir
    a esta destacada empresa y para felicitarles por que se lo merecen,
    y sobre todo les doy muchas gracias por la pacienci que tuvieron conigo puesto
    que debo reconocer que soy una persona muy dificil, estuve buscando durante un par de meses
    empresas de reformas en madrid y preguntando a
    la gente, metiendome en foros de discusión, web, etc.
    He de decir que yo también estuve muy sobre los ultimos remates y acabados, pero solo fueron los primeros días después ya empece a fiarme de ellos, si necesitais una empresa de reformas os aconsejo conteis con profesionales como esta empresa.
    Precisaba una compañía de reformas profesional y seria, no queria abaratar
    puesto que mas bien queria calidad y una obra con bastante emergencia pues tenia
    que abrir mi negocio en menos de 20 días. Esta gente pese a que
    tuvieron sus inconvenientes con mi reforma
    han sabido salir de todo los problemas con calma y han llevado la administración de la
    reforma bastante bien, no nos engañemos en todas las reformas hay problemas, al final todo acabo con acabados
    profesionales y todos y cada uno de los trabajos muy bien, si buscais una compañía
    de reformas en la villa de Madrid profesional acudir a Hábitat Rehabilita

  103. . It allows an individual to connect to the Net without authorizing any kind of contract with the mobile

  104. Aundrea says:

    Great info. Lucky me I recently found your
    site by accident (stumbleupon). I have saved as a favorite for

  105. Thanks , I’ve recently been looking for info about this subject for a while and yours is the greatest I have found out
    till now. But, what concerning the bottom line? Are you positive about the source?

  106. Also make sure to never let Patrat go against a stronger Pokémon, even when it is level
    100, since Patrat’s max stats are still much weaker than other Pokémon at a lower level.
    movie in the true sense of the word (the word for a collection of spices) as a bollywood movie showcases all human emotions of happiness, anger, love
    and grief. Around the world, the quantity of individuals mulling
    over Japanese expanded.


    عرب شاترز , شات عرب شاترز, موقع عرب شاترز , عرب شاترز بيتكوين , بطاقات فيزا مجانية ,
    تفعيل البايبال , بيتكوين مجانى كل دقيقة , ساتوشي مجانا , مسابقات بيتكوين , شراء وبيع البيتكوين , شات الجزائر , بيتكوين شات , سعر البيتكوين ,

  108. Hi there, for all time i used to check blog posts here in the early hours in the dawn,
    for the reason that i enjoy to gain knowledge of more
    and more.

  109. Im Webcam Sex Chat hast Du auch die Möglichkeit Telefonsex mit geilen Amateuren vor der Livecam zu machen.

  110. ass says:

    StumbleUpon also helps you to edit your interest to find more pages that interest you.

  111. cost to rent a roll off dumpster
    large garbage containers rent

  112. portable toilets for hire cost
    additional info

  113. Multi piece rods

    Cage Match: Pension vs. 401k • Systematic Relative Strength • Dorsey Wright Money Management Systematic Relative Strength