Market Timing with CAPE

How worried should you be when you hear someone say that the market is overvalued?

Wesley Gray at Alpha Architect takes a deep dive into the topic of timing the market using CAPE, Shiller’s Cyclically Adjusted PE ratio in a recent post.  His results should give pause to even he most strident market timing fundamentalist.  He also looked at market timing using simple trend following (trend following performed better!).  His methods are described below (study covered the period 1/1/1947 – 1/31/2015):

To create our “valuation-timing” indicator, every month we identify the 99 percentile valuations using rolling 5-, 10-, and 20-year look-back periods. Our trading rule is simple: if the current market valuation is greater or equal to the 99 percentile measure, we invest in the risk-free rate (short-term treasury bills), otherwise, we stay invested.

We compare the valuation-timing indicator to a monthly-assessed simple moving-average (MA) trading rule, and a buy-and-hold strategy. The buy-and-hold strategy is straightforward, and the MA indicator is simple: if the current market price is lower than the 12 month moving average, we invest in the risk-free rate (short-term treasury bills), otherwise, we stay invested.

Our conclusion is counterintuitive, but not entirely surprising:

Strategy Legend:
• SP500 = S&P 500 Total Return Index
• LTR = The Merrill Lynch 10-year U.S. Treasury Futures Total Return Index
• Rolling 5 year 99perc CAPE= Timing signal uses the 99th percentile valuation metric using rolling 5 year look-back periods.
• Rolling 10 year 99perc CAPE = Timing signal uses the 99th percentile valuation metric using rolling 10 year look-back periods.
• Rolling 20 year 99perc CAPE= Timing signal uses the 99th percentile valuation metric using rolling 20 year look-back periods.
• (1,12) MA= If last month’s price is above the past 12 month average, invest in the S&P 500; otherwise, buy U.S. Treasury Bills (RF).

The results are hypothetical results and are NOT an indicator of future results and do NOT represent returns that any investor actually attained. Indexes are unmanaged, do not reflect management or trading fees, and one cannot invest directly in an index. Additional information regarding the construction of these results is available upon request.

Conclusion

There is no evidence to support the use of “valuation-timing,” which performs similarly to buy-and-hold strategies (after costs it would we much worse). There is nothing magical about the 99th percentile. Trend-following, at least historically, seems to more effective.

Perhaps there are more convoluted, complex, and data-optimized ways in which we can leverage overall market valuations to help us time markets. We haven’t found any, but that doesn’t mean they don’t exist. Please share.

Pretty shocking results.  If you can’t even successfully identify overvalued markets when a market is in the 99th valuation percentile, then why even pay any attention to valuation measures at all?  If someone wants to be bearish, there is always some seemingly plausible reason and CAPE valuation measures are an often-cited reason.  However, Gray’s study is a solid takedown of the idea that CAPE can be effectively used as a way to get out of the market at the right time.  As pointed out in his study, a simple trend following method worked better.  Perhaps, an even more promising approach is a relative strength-driven Tactical Asset Allocation strategy as is detailed in this white paper by our own John Lewis.

I agree with a recent tweet by Cullen Roche:

FYI, no one knows how “expensive” the market really is or how “expensive” it really should be.

A reality that investors would do well to embrace.

The relative strength strategy is NOT a guarantee.  There may be times where all investment sand strategies are unfavorable and depreciate in value.

32 Responses to Market Timing with CAPE

1. […] Marketing Timing with CAPE [Systematic Relative Strength] How worried should you be when you hear someone say that the market is overvalued? Wesley Gray at Alpha Architect takes a deep dive into the topic of timing the market using CAPE, Shiller’s Cyclically Adjusted… […]

2. […] about CAPE and other valuation model warnings? Dorsey Wright explains that even the extreme readings on these measures have not been […]

Market Timing with CAPE  Systematic Relative Strength  Dorsey Wright Money Management Systematic Relative Strength

4. Simply wish to say your article is as astonishing.
The clarity on your put up is simply spectacular and
that i could suppose you’re an expert in this subject.

with impending post. Thanks one million and please carry on the rewarding work.

5. my site says:

This kind of makes it possible in order to seee through just like thhe sunglass

6. Gfgfgfg.com says:

You should take part in a contest for one of the highest quality websites online.
I most certainly will recommend this blog!

8. srank.me says:

Despite confusing reports reports, the basics of healthy eating are actually quite straightforward.

9. cablingjobs says:

And finally, the cabling installers return to install the cabling system on the
furniture by adding the columns and top-caps and vertical
wire hangers.

10. ” 84% of survey respondents answered Yes.

11. Thee posts in this series have been underwritten with the
particular support of Vodafone Numerous Foundation.

12. Currencies always drop and rise depending on the situation as
well as the reasons for their fluctuations depend on a number
of factors. Check out this cool nial fuller interview to understand more about him and
losses. You can have a look at for more free FOREX tools and information. The trade could be followed while using help of simple trade formula, which consists from the value of
an currency, the BOP formula as well as the stability of the nation in world trade market.

It is very recommended that you always place a
stop loss order to ensure your losses will be cut quickly.

13. Thanks to my father who informed me on the topic off this webpage, this webpage is really amazing.

Market Timing with CAPE  Systematic Relative Strength  Dorsey Wright Money Management Systematic Relative Strength

15. Wilhemina says:

fantastic points altogether, you just gained a brand new reader.
What could you suggest fun in sydney (Wilhemina) regards to your submit
that you just made a few days in the past? Any certain?

16. penzu.com says:

penzu.com

Market Timing with CAPE  Systematic Relative Strength  Dorsey Wright Money Management Systematic Relative Strength

17. At this time I am ready to do my breakfast, afterward having my breakfast coming again to read additional news.

18. 私が訪れたいくつかの サイト しかししかしオーディオ品質オーディオの曲のためにこれを サイト 純粋に本当に 優れたです。

19. いくつかのいずれか場合は欲望エキスパート·ビューのトピックについて その後その後私はお勧め 訪問に彼/彼女の いい続けてくださいこのブログを払う 仕事。
期間限定送料無料 一部予約販売 http://www.przedszkolemalbork.pl/

20. 極上後しかし、 |あなたはこのトピックの詳細リッテを書くことができれば、私は知りたい思ってい ？あなたは少し手の込んだことができれば、| 感謝感謝 をさらに私は非常になるだろう。 あなたを祝福！
最安値に挑戦中 3日間限定 http://www.kataque.com/

21. What’s Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I have discovered It absolutely helpful and it has
aided me out loads. I hope to give a contribution & assist different customers like its aided me.
Great job.

22. my site says:

I was pretty pleased to uncover this site.
I wanted to thank you for your time just for this fantastic read!!
I definitely appreciated every bit of it and i also have
you book marked to look at new information in your web site.

23. Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I have really loved surfing around your blog
posts. After all I’ll be subscribing for your feed and I’m hoping you write again very
soon!

24. Magnificent goods from you, man. I have understand your stuff previous
to and you’re just too great. I really like what you’ve acquired here, really like what
you are stating and the way in which you say it.
You make it entertaining and you still care for to keep it
sensible. I can’t wait to read much more from you. This is
really a tremendous web site.

25. steceb.net says:

I know this site offers quality based posts and extra information, is there any other website which presents these kinds
of stuff in quality?

26. my blog says:

Awesome! Its really awesome paragraph, I have got much clear idea
on the topic of from this paragraph.

27. Hey there! I’m at work surfing around yoour blog from myy new iphone
and look forward to all your posts! Carry onn the fantastic work!

28. Great items from you, man. I’ve be aware your stuff previous to and you’re simply too excellent. I really like what you’ve acquired here, really like what you are saying and the best way through which you assert it. You make it entertaining and you continue to take care of to keep it wise. I can not wait to learn much more from you. That is really a wonderful site.

29. Rochell says:

You made some good points there. I checked on the net
to find out more about the issue and found most individuals will goo along with your views on this web site.

30. There are lots of travel, cruise, sight seeing tour buses, plus much more, that may takes place help,
by helping them get new, plus much more customers.
On of the slope, your vehicle will roll uphill whenever you remove your foot from the brake.
1 – Transportation – Planes, Trains & Buses – If you are travelling by plane or train make
sure you always pick an aisle seat to only access the toilets
when nature calls.

31. We arе а gaggle оf volunteers аnd starting a new scheme іn ouг community.

Ⲩouг site offered սs with usefսl infoгmation tⲟ worқ on. Υоu have dⲟne a formidable task and our entіre neighborhood can be thankful to yοu.

32. Very clear web site, appreciate it for this post.